“Let your inner beauty blossom!” “Be authentic!” “Embrace yourself!” These seemingly well-meaning Beauty & Wellness mantras sound like marketing clichés, right? Well, our latest Creative Analytics report shows that they really do reflect people’s perception of beauty and it appears many beauty brands are listening.
But while people’s beliefs, and the marketing messages they hear, may be focused more and more on Inner beauty, society’s values have some catching up to do. Why, if people value Inner beauty does society still reward those with Outer beauty? Let’s take a closer look.
People place inner beauty above outer beauty
People put more stock in Inner beauty (who you are) over Outer beauty (how you look). And they are doing so in 3 key ways.
How We View Ourselves:
People rate their own internal beauty higher than their external. In fact, hardly anyone (aside from those asshole narcissists) feels good about their Outer beauty without also feeling good about their Inner beauty
How We Want Others to View Us:
People prefer to be complimented for ‘who they are’ over ‘how they look’. Our findings uncovered that overall qualities such as happiness, kindness, confidence, humor, and intelligence are more highly valued than the external appearance of your skin, the shape of your body, hairstyle or make-up.
How We View Others:
Internal beauty matters more than looks when finding others attractive. 62% of people thinking that beauty or attraction comes from the inside and not the outside.
The beauty industry is catching on
The beauty industry is inherently one that creates products intended to transform, enhance or mask our external, physical features. However, as people’s beliefs shift towards the internal, we have seen the industry recognize the importance of inner beauty and shift their messaging to a more real, authentic, and human definition of beauty.
Companies have embraced that inner beauty affects outer beauty. There has been an increasing focus on sustainable products to overall living well. From the focus on feeling beautiful inside, at any age, emerged the boom of self-care products, supplements and simply daily yoga.
The messaging around beauty products, themselves, has also shifted.
- Back in 2004, Dove’s “Real Beauty” campaign widened the definition of beauty and encouraged women to embrace their natural selves.
- Tatcha, recently acquired by Unilever, was built around the ancient culture of Geishas: “Beauty begins in the heart and the mind, and that beauty is something that’s gained with age—not lost. When you are younger it’s at the surface, but as you get older it deepens and becomes intrinsic as your heart and mind become more beautiful.”
- Selena Gomez’s “Rare Beauty” brand is all about embracing inner beauty. “Being rare is about being comfortable with yourself.”
- Dermablend introduced a new perspective on makeup: “Blend in to stand out” suggesting that makeup covers imperfections so that women can reveal who they are inside.
Yet society still rewards the external
The idea of beauty is always shifting. Mainstream television, media outlets and social media have had us believing for years that only a select few are blessed with the gift of beauty. That their depiction of beauty is something we should aspire to. Influencer culture that perpetuates unrealistic images on Instagram is partly to blame for fueling this belief.
The shift to unfiltered images of celebrities & social media influencers and empowering slogans in ads may be surface-level gestures.
While people place more value on what’s on the inside, regardless of gender and age they still believe outward appearance fuels success.
Both men and women believe physical beauty drives success in life. This feeling peaks in people’s 50’s, many of whom may be in the height of careers.
And many people still feel expectations of beauty are unrealistic. This is significantly greater for women in general, but particularly among older generations. A fascinating point to be made, though, is that younger people feel those expectations are almost as unrealistic for men as women. Is that a function of their age and lack of ‘real-life’ experiences or are tides changing? And what does it infer about unrealistic expectations for men?
The Sound musings
The definition of beauty will keep changing, but what will remain constant is that internal beauty really does matter over the external charm. For the beauty industry, is it just a new momentum? Will society catch up?
The beauty industry lives in the middle of individual/internal vs. society/external tension – their products are for the external, but their messaging is aimed at the internal. This begs the question, beyond changes in messaging, how can an inherently external industry authentically shift to one that is about internal beauty?
And if society continues to reward external beauty, will the pendulum swing back?
Digging deeper into perceptions of Inner versus Outer beauty we found that our self-perception of our Outer beauty, our looks and appearance, peaks in our 20’s and stays fairly consistent into our 60’s.
Ideals of exterior beauty are being formed in our formative years – think the messy teen years of hating your reflection, learning to accept your flaws, figuring out what suits us in clothes, make up, fragrance etc. These are solidified as we mature into true adulthood during our 20’s. Life gets real. We’ve learned who we are through friendships and work, probably had a sexual partner (or a few) and we become accepting of our appearance and more comfortable. The curly hair and pale skin you hated as a teen become your defining features as an adult. You accept your appearance for how it is. This acceptance in our 20’s carries us through to our middle and old age. The importance of external beauty peaks and plateaus.
As we age, our self-perception of inner beauty continually increases and peaks in our 50s.
Gender norms still apply
Unsurprisingly perhaps, gender also plays a role in shaping beauty perceptions. Men put a bit more importance on looks, though ‘who people are on the inside’ is still the primary influence.
Inner beauty is important overall – but the definition of Inner beauty also depends on your gender. In order to be considered attractive, men should have the following traits: Intelligent, Knowledgeable, Wise, Funny, Entertaining, Happy. The shocking fact is that through the eyes of both genders at every age, women’s top personality traits remain fairly consistent (and more about what they do for others, than who they actually are) – Caring, Compassionate, Generous, Sincere, Trusting, Altruistic. In the age of gender equality, it just doesn’t sound right. Read more about the Power of Likability in Attraction here.
Want to chat more about it? Download the report and let’s start the debate!